Monthly Archives: October 2014

Old Pulteney ‘Clipper’

Bought – The Whisky Shop, 30th September 2014

93/100 – Whisky Bible 2015
83.29/100 – Whiskybase (average from 9 member votes)

I always thought a ‘clipper’ was the teacher at school that used to give kids a clip around the ear for being naughty but apparently it’s a sort of boat too. One that Old Pulteney entered in a race around the world, heading off from London in September 2013 and arriving back in July 2014. The Clipper bottling celebrates this journey. The ‘Old Pulteney’ was the only Scottish entrant in the race and a cunning way for the distillery to spread its name around the world. One of 12 ships taking part, the Old Pulteney clipper would get plenty of press coverage, and dock in various countries along the way with local natives asking “what’s this Old Pulteney stuff?!” Here’s one of the videos taken on board the ‘Old Pulteney’ clipper during its voyage:

For me, this bottle signifies a change in my whisky collecting. The Whisky Shop took 5 weeks to get a bottle in after I requested it. As a result the price had gone down £5 elsewhere so I naturally asked them to match it. Instead they offered me free membership of their W Club (normally £12.50), so I accepted. A good move on their part because the 10% discount I now get as a member has already encouraged me to buy a few bottles. I’ve also been asked to go on their tasting panel and report back my thoughts to other members via their website. Me?! Write about whisky?! Hmmm. 😉

Old Pulteney Clipper NAS 70cl


Glenlivet ‘Nadurra’ 16-year-old batch 0313W

Bought – Sainsbury’s, 22th September 2014

88.5/100 – Whisky Bible 2016
86/100 – Best Shot Whisky Reviews
5/5 Stars – Master of Malt (from 2 ratings)

It only takes one person on a whisky forum to say “I think they’re replacing the Nadurra 16-year-old with a non-aged statement Nadurra” to put me in a panic. Even though someone else added “that’s rubbish!” I was instantly thinking I had to get another Nadurra 16yo before stocks ran out. I’m now wondering if a member of staff at Glenlivet goes around the whisky forums making these comments so idiots like me rush out and spend. If so, it worked!

I bought my first bottle of Nadurra back in May 2014, a potent 56.1% from batch number 0813Y. This latest bottle is from batch 0313W and a less feisty 54.8%. Not that I’ll notice the difference because at that strength I’ll always add a bit of water.

The Nadurra is one of the few cask strength whiskies available in the UK supermarkets, and as we approach Christmas it’s an ideal gift if you want to give a whisky drinker something different. To keep an eye on the various supermarket deals I’m still using my trusty friend mySupermarket.

Here’s Andy of Malt Box on You Tube giving his review of batch 0313W, which he scores 87/100 (April 2016):

Glenlivet Nadurra 16yo 70cl batch 0313W

Bowmore ‘Small Batch Reserve’

Bought – Sainsbury’s, 22th September 2014

80.5/100 – Whisky Bible 2014
81.78/100 – Whiskybase (average from 69 member votes)

I’d hate to know what Bowmore describe as a “Large Batch” given how long I’ve seen bottles of this “small” batch on the shelves of local supermarkets. Perhaps a large batch of Bowmore would go on forever, or until someone noticed that the level of the Irish Sea had gone down. Thankfully I can’t see any fish swimming around in my bottle!

The Whisky Bible has very little to say about this single malt. Small by name, small by review. It does however score 21/25 for taste, which equates to a very respectable 84/100. Just shy of 82/100 on Whiskybase is a surprisingly good score with comments of “well made for a young malt” and “seriously good value for money”.

As I write this, Morrisons supermarket have this Bowmore for £24.99 but I’m stunned to see that The Whisky Exchange online are trying to sell it for £36.99! It’s certainly not worth that much. £25 is a fair price for this non-aged statement single malt that will give you a pleasant taste experience from a good, well established Islay distillery.

Here’s Horst Luening of on You Tube with his thoughts about this entry-level Bowmore (April 2014):

Bowmore Small Batch Reserve 70cl

Elijah Craig 12-year-old

Bought – Marks & Spencer, 16th September 2014

79/100 – Whisky Bible 2014
91/100 – RalfyElijah Craig 12yo – YouTube (October 2010)
– In Ian Buxton’s book “101 Whiskies to Try Before You Die”

You might be wondering why I have two bottles in the picture below. So am I. Marks & Spencer were selling it for £5 less than anywhere else, even online. When I bought a bottle they gave me a ‘£5 Off’ voucher if I spent £25 or more so I got another bottle, this time £10 less than anywhere else. 2015 was meant to be my bourbon year but it looks like I’ve started early. Perhaps a lucky friend or relative will be getting my second bottle for Christmas.

I need to get the Whisky Bible 2011, which will include bourbons the author (Jim Murray) tried in 2010 when Ralfy also reviewed the Elijah Craig. In 1996, the distillery that produce Elijah Craig was mostly destroyed in a fire. The 12yo reviewed in the 2009 bible gets 86/100 but the author is suspicious that this is old stock, rather than an example of post-fire production. By 2014 Jim Murray knows the bourbon is from the new distillery and he’s not exactly complimentary. I’d be interested to know what Ralfy would think if it now.

The good news is that the majority of recent reviews for this bourbon on ‘Master of Malt’ are 5/5 stars. I adore the bottle shape, and the 47% is a good strength to give the drink some depth. I also see that the last reviewer for this bourbon on Whiskybase gives it 93/100. Perhaps I’ll be keeping that second bottle after all!

Update (22nd Dec 2014). I’ve tried this bourbon over several months, with various amounts of water. My conclusion is, add something! Coke, ginger ale, whatever. I think the Whisky Bible mark of 79/100 is generous. There’s no way of hiding the ‘burnt’ element of this spirit without a stronger, sweet mixer, with good masking skills. I wish I’d had a chance to experience the old version of Elijah Craig because this version is, sadly, terrible. If you get a bottle, I’d recommend drinking it at the end of the night when better drink has numbed your taste buds!

Elijah Craig 12yo 70cl

Laphroaig 10-year-old

Bought – Morrisons, 13th September 2014

90/100 – Whisky Bible 2014
89/100 – RalfyLaphroaig 10yo (Islay Region) – YouTube (May 2013)

What whisky collection would be complete without the Laphroaig 10-year-old?! It’s an Islay classic, which Jim Murray in his Whisky Bible opens his remarks with “impossible not to nose this and think of Islay”. Personally I’ve never been to Islay but, if it smells like the Laphroaig 10yo, you’d only have to take a deep breath to get drunk! Sounds like my sort of place. Mr Murray says about the taste “one of the crispiest, peaty malts of them all” and apparently it’s a favourite of Prince Charles. That fact alone might have made him King of Scotland had independence been declared. That’s assuming Rab C. Nesbitt wasn’t available.

Looking at the scores from Whiskybase and Malt Maniacs, they’re mid to high 80s out of 100, which is excellent. Basically, if you like peated whisky, or want to try a full-on peat experience, the Laphroaig 10yo is the one to go for. It’s in most supermarkets in the UK, and easily available online around the £30-£34 mark. If you like it then next on the Islay shopping list would be the Ardbeg 10yo at around £40-£45.

Laphroaig 10yo 70cl

Glenmorangie 12-year-old ‘Quinta Ruban’

Bought – Morrisons, 11th September 2014

92/100 – Whisky Bible 2014
89/100 – RalfyGlenmorangie Quinta Ruban – YouTube (March 2014)

Ralfy’s comparison between the ‘Quinta Ruban’ and the old ‘Port Wood’ finish by Glenmorangie is very interesting, especially as I have a miniature of the Port Wood from an auction last year. Once I get around to cracking open the Ruban I’ll have to do my own taste compassion with my mini.

Would you walk into a bar and ask for a bourbon and port cocktail? Probably not, unless you were so drunk you were close to standing on a table and singing songs about goblins and giant Martians eating your house. The Quinta Rubin has gone through a process of double maturation, spending most of its initial life sucking the flavour out of bourbon casks, then being finished for a period in port casks. The flavour combination sounds a bit suspect but Jim Murray, author of the Whisky Bible, summarises his review with “this is a form of cask finishing that has progressed from experimentation to certainty”. And who better to get it right than the 16 men of Glenmorangie when they’re not busy with their 8-a-side football matches.

If you like Highland single malts but want something a bit different then the Quinta Ruban is worth tracking down. In the UK several supermarkets stock it, and with Christmas approaching there’s a good chance it will get discounted. Morrisons had a mad moment and reduced it to £27.99. Sadly I’d bought it the week before when they’d initially discounted it to £35. Even at that price it was a bargain.

Glenmorangie 12yo Quinta Ruban 70cl

Macallan ‘Gold’

Gift – Nickolls & Perks, 9th September 2014

89.5/100 – Whisky Bible 2014
80.38/100 – Whiskybase (average from 60 member votes)

I’d tried the Macallan ‘Gold’ in a bar in Scotland and was considering buying a full bottle until Nickolls & Perks sent me a free miniature with my last order. As a collector this ticks it off the list for a while but I’d still like to get a full bottle eventually. The Whisky Bible says of the taste “it is the (chocolate) biscuity barley laced with honey and maple syrup that blows you away” and the author summaries with “no Macallan I have tasted since the first in 1975 has been sculpted to show the distillery in such delicate form.”

The average score and comments on Whiskybase are a little less grandiose than in the Whisky Bible. Having tried the Gold I would agree with a member of Whiskybase who describes it as an entry-level single malt. If you’re after a good Speysider at a reasonable price then the Macallan ‘Gold’ is certainly a contender. But it’s a bit like getting a pair of tartan socks for Christmas – it’s OK, definitely warming, certainly Scottish but nothing to write home about.

I’ve been monitoring the price of the Macallan ‘Gold’ in UK supermarkets for over a year now and it’s never been discounted from its price of £36, which has started to creep up in some locations. £36 puts it in the same price bracket, or slightly more than a discounted Aberlour A’bunadh, which smashes the Gold out of sight for nose, body, flavour, taste, strength, finish and being everything good about Speyside. For what the Gold is, it should be £30 maximum but you’re paying £6 more because of the Macallan name. Heck, who am I kidding?! I’m a designer labels whore so I’ll be getting a full bottle soon! 🙂

Here’s Jo of Whisky Wednesday with his thoughts on the Macallan Gold, which he scores 7.5/100 (YouTube Nov 2015):

Macallan Gold 5cl

Macallan 12-year-old ‘Sherry Oak’

Bought – Nickolls & Perks, 9th September 2014

93/100 – Whisky Bible 2014
84.87/100 – Whiskybase (average from 229 member votes)
88/100 – Whisky Bitch – Her review on YouTube (February 2014)

There are times during any form of collecting, be it whisky, stamps, shoes, motorbikes, etc, when you can have a mad moment. This can often be followed by a collector questioning why they do what they do, especially if they also believe in saving the planet, helping the poor and curing cancer. For me these moments of doubt can hit at any time but especially if I spend a lot of money on a whisky that doesn’t really merit the price tag. Enter the Macallan 12yo ‘Sherry Oak’. A mere snip at £66 in September but already a month later it’s up to £74 and rising. But it’s been discontinues, and getting rarer, so shops are gradually hiking the price. My brother remembers it when it used to be about £30, and that’s within the last 10 years. But I’ve fallen into the trap of thinking the Macallan is collectable for a future profit, if I don’t end up drinking it first.

Jim Murray rates the 12yo ‘Sherry Oak’ below the 12yo ‘Fine Oak’ but it’s the other way around with the votes from Whiskybase which are:

  • 84.87/100 – 12yo Sherry Oak, average from 229 votes
  • 81.68/100 – 12yo Fine Oak, average from 151 votes

Personally I do love a more sherried Speysider so I’m likely to side with those on Whiskybase instead of Mr Murray. But when two whiskies are as close as that, you can sometimes find it depends on the day as to which one you prefer. There’s a whisky for all moods, emotions and seasons.

Macallan 12yo Sherry Oak 70cl

Ardbeg Corryvreckan

Bought – Nickolls & Perks, 9th September 2014

96.5/100 – Whisky Bible 2014
90/100 – Ralfy (his video review below)
89.37/100 – Whiskybase (average from 719 member votes)

If you’d asked me a year ago if I’d get a Corryvreckan before a bottle of Uigeadail I would have said “Corry what?!” I only became aware of the Corryvreckan when I saw it in a ‘World Duty Free’ shop in Heathrow Airport. I did a bit of research and discovered that a heck of a lot of people LOVE this whisky, not least Jim Murray in his Whisky Bible 2014. He waxes lyrical about its wonders, scoring the overall balance and complexity a perfect 25/25. Apparently the taste isn’t too bad either, which Mr Murray scores 24.5/25 and begins his comments with “amazing”! You also don’t get nearly 90/100 from 719 member votes on Whiskybase if you’re not close to perfection. It seems that, Islay fan or not, you’d still get some pleasure out of the Corryvreckan.

Corryvreckan is from the Gaelic meaning “fan of Coronation Street” or “cauldron of the speckled sea”, or one of those. Whatever it means, Ardbeg clearly didn’t give it a name that would be easy to say when a pub rang for last orders. After your 10th slurred attempt at saying it I’d recommend settling with “a beer please”. But you’re unlikely to find the Corryvreckan in a bar. Even the Ardbeg 10yo is generally only located in specialist whisky bars. It’s a shame but then perhaps that’s deliberate by Ardbeg who want to be more exclusive.

Here’s Ralfy with his thoughts about the Corryvreckan on YouTube (April 2010):

Ardbeg Corryvreckan 70cl

The Famous Jubilee

Bought – Waitrose, 7th September 2014

83.5/100 – Whisky Bible 2014

OK Waitrose, OK! I get the message! I’ve never seen so many former prices on a sales label before. “£25.60 reduced to £22, reduced to £20, reduced to £16, reduced to £14”. I’d considered The Famous Jubilee a month or so ago when it was £16 but it was my cousin saying he’d got it for £14 that prompted me to finally get it. What the heck! It’s hardly going to become valuable as a collector’s piece, and I don’t suppose it will set the taste buds dancing but you rarely see a special edition whisky for as little as £14 these days.

Jim Murray’s bible mark of 83.5/100 is very respectable. Even more so when you realise he spotted sulphur in it and deducts marks for that. For those like me who can’t detect sulphur (and don’t want to) it could score into the 90s! Mr Murray says “heavyweight, stodgy, toffee-laden kind of blend a long way from the Grouse tradition.” And “there are redeeming rich honey tones that are a joy.” 83.5/100 ranks it as a “good whisky worth trying” and why not for £14, given how insistent Waitrose have been.

God save the Queen, and all who drink with her!

Famous Jubilee 70cl